- Wed Feb 24, 2010 2:52 pm
#406456
But the Roger's phrase is about a person - the cotton picking is about an activity - that's my point.
Cotton picker - yes. Cotton picking - no.
But I know what you mean, and thank you kindly
Yudster wrote:The daft thing is Wykey, that when it comes down to it we actually hold the same opinion really. I'm in complete agreement with you that people are far too quick to assume racial motivations for things we just SAY, and the idea that we should all censor our conversation to such a huge extent makes me more than irritated. All I'm doing is trying to put the view of the people who ARE offended - whether we agree with it or not, they have their reasons. Its quite possible that Morgan Freeman could be as offended by Fearne Cotton saying "Cotton, like in "cotton-pickin'"" as he would have been by Roger Black saying "Black, as in "black as the massa's boy"". For him, the connotations could be exactly the same because the colloquialised phrases both stem from the same historical context - its just far more obvious to non African Americans that the second one (which I haven't heard for years thank goodness) would be offensive.
And yes, "Whether you like ot or not" was a ridiculous thing to say, I apologise.
But the Roger's phrase is about a person - the cotton picking is about an activity - that's my point.
Cotton picker - yes. Cotton picking - no.
But I know what you mean, and thank you kindly