[DJPhil]

did anyone one see his big band show?<br>I thought it was absoloutly brilliant, well done Rob.<br>Im deffinetly gonna but the "swing when your winning album" when it comes out(monday I think)

[wannabe_mrs_moyles]

nope, i recorded it for my sister though so i might watch it later. all the reviews said it was great.

[Guest]

Yeah it was great made a change really good to watch. <br>The album is great worth money for sure. <br>

[Uglybob]

sorry to pee on your bonfire but:<br><br>page 562 of bbc teletext<br>q magazine 2/5 review

[DJPhil]

couldn't care less what the reviews say, I prefer to make my own mind up rather than let other people do it for me  :) and think it was a blinding performance. Well done Mr Williams

[Everlast]

Im sorry but i saw parts of that and i thought it was shit making a swing album and doing a duet with Nicola Skidman is his way of self destructing. I suppose a swing album was probably to convince people that he isn't a one trick pony, and he isn't he can sing and pull his pants down at the same time(wow this mans talent has no boundries), and telling the Dandy warhols lead singer Courtney Taylor that he smells of poo is just soooooo * weak to. Another thing is that Robbie Williams is gay, he has always been camp and is always saying how he'd like to try sleeping with men he will probably come out the same week that his * opera CD comes out next year.

[jupiterlove]

I thought it was fantastic. It was so obvious he was loving every minute and i thought his voice was superb.<br>Would like to have sen the full show live..cos the atmosphere looked electric. I think he is very brave to do something as diverse as to revert to the music of the great entertainers..it could have gone VERY wrong. But fortunately for him and for us it was a complete success. Thought his duet with Johnathan Wilkes was fantastic. Well done Robbie..you have now completely escaped the dodgy days of take that!!!!!

[Everlast]

I think Robbie Williams is very overated and i also think that Craig David is more talented. Craig David can cut UK Garage, UK R+B, crack the American charts which Robbie hasn't and i heard him do a brilliant Lennon cover, i even heard Craig David Freestyle a verse on Simon Mayo's show in the middle of "seven days" which changed my mind about him.<br>Im not a fan of Craig David but i recognise his talents.

[Gaspode_The_Wonder_Dog]

i think everybody is equally great. except radiohead who are crap.

[Guest]

radiohead arse........<br>gabrielle was good, now arse<br>jane mac donald- in league with the devil

[Guest]

Let me explain something to you people - there is a scale on which all music is listed.  Robbie is on the top of this scale, Radiohead is at the very bottem.  Thankyou for your kind attention to this message.

[Ionic_Storm]

I would point out the "bottem" but it seems too obvious

[wannabe_mrs_moyles]

hehe! and where's michael jackson in this scale? half the people i know think he's great and the other half think he's crap!

[Guest]

Depends on if you are talkin about his old stuff or the music he is come up with now! I now which one is better.  :)

[Guest]

i personally like robbie very much, which is slightly odd since i'm a punk indie kid from ameirca.  but then again i also like hearsay.<br><br>why do people call radiohead genius. it's pure pretentious crap that all the kids who want to be percieved as smart listen to.<br><br>you people post way too much crap. like this post.<br><br>

[Lawrie]

hang on a minute your slating a group who play all their instruments and have made 5 of the best albums the rock world has ever seen and yet your singing the praises of a guy who was in the worst boy band ever who CO -writes his material who is a PERFORMER more than a singer. <br>Please think before typing! radiohead are an amazing band full of talent who make stunning music.<br><br>Robbie williams is a great performer who has some good songs but to say he is better than radiohead is pure stupidity<br><br>Hoare you are a complete arse my friend

[Jessntell]

Both are good, there we go, we all happy now  ;) <br>

[Guest]

whining into a microphone with dissonant music in the backgroung is neither beuatiful nor genius.

[Uglybob]

pretentious good word, after ok computer they suck big donkey balls

[Lawrie]

prenentious? as if! they are years ahead of other rock groups in the UK and US

[a_girl_from_mars]

sorry, I don't want to be percieved as anything but I like Radiohead. I don't have any of the albums and only one single but I think they are brilliant.

[Jessntell]

Look DRLOZBAKER, thats in your opinion. Just accpet that there are people out there who dont like them and prefer herasay or something. There opinion is no more valid than your own so dont blow out just because they say your wrong. Im not the biggest fan of either of the bands mentioned but they're good in there own way.

[Guest]

if you mean "i don't understand it, therefore it must be brilliant and ahead of it's time because it's painfully cryptic" then yes.<br><br>i've listened to them over the years, and it's been a decline after ok computer.  i think there's a talent and beauty in being the performer.  people can't be so wrapped up in "the music" espicially if it's crap and not very entertaining. robbie williams is ace at this.  radiohead is ace at speaking to pseudointellectual mopey kids. or at least that's their role in america.<br><br>

[Uglybob]

come on there are worse bands out there who we all hate. we should all unite to rid the world of <br><br><br>THE * LIGHTHOUSE FAMILY

[Guest]

how about.... i dunno. i can't be so blatant.