[I Want Errr.... Cake]

Chris just played it, but do you reckon it's good or not?

[David]

Starts off really good, I like it... but it steadily gets worse through out the track...

[Andy Bkr]

after a few listens could be better than the original

[Sidders]

I've not heard it yet. I'm looking forward to Dizzie's rap.

[Quincy]

its ok, not as good as the original, but i think dizzie rascals rap is rubbish

[Sidders]

Some of the mixing's dodgy. It reminds me of mine and Staticfish's Thongbird effort.

[Betti911]

Not as good as the original... I prefer to give my money straight to charity this Christmas.

[Mcqueen_]

It's just alright.

They could of done a totally new song instead of trying to make the old one more 'modern'.

[pip1984_2k]

It will still be massive, there's no doubt in that!

[Sidders]

I'm going to wait to hear it a few more times before criticising it. There seems to be a bit of a hate bandwagon going on at the moment.

[Tom Holt]

as moyles always says when he gets a first play: "it's a grower"

Let's just hope it grows before christmas....

[Toast]

Love it.

[Marky]

It definatly gets better the more i hear it, but still mediocre. It had so much potential, with the all the 'stars' taking part....

[Betti911]

I like some of the people in it but the song really wasn't meant for their voices. For example Dido is a great live singer with an unusual voice but sounds crap in Band Aid 20.

[seanbhoy]

Like Moyles said: could be a grower

[Golden Syrup]

dizzee and justin hawkins part is good, the rest just sounds like a bit like an office christmas party doing karaoke (sp?). i'll probably end up buying it though, it's for a damn good cause!

[Sidders]

I quite like it now. I downloaded it from http://www.bandaid20.com/

It's probably better to download it if you want it, because not as much money will need to be spent marketing the download.

[Quincy]

i still dont like it.

[Gaspode_The_Wonder_Dog]

i have donated £9.99 to KFC instead to help the depressed fast food market.

[Golden Syrup]

i know some people who are planning to stage an animal rights protest outside out local kfc.

i like the band aid song as a song but i think this version could have been so much better when you think how many talented musicians and singers are on this track. the chorus sounds like everyone's trying to be louder than everyone else, i they wanted that they should have gone to a football ground

[Marky]

I've downloaded it. Shame they've made it a WMA - doesn't work on my 'old skool' mp3 player :/