Topher wrote:You are right, of course, but I'm not sure they've ever had anyone leave the show who was as integral as Dom has become and really, it would be a massive gap to fill now.
I agree Topher, there would be a massive gap to fill if Dom left, it was the same with Will & Lizzie for me, whilst Rhys & Melinda were great on air, Rhys was often off on management courses & today has ended up as one of the higher managers of BBC Radio (be it Radio 1, Five Live or Asian Network, I believe he's worked at all of these at some point) and Melinda was a great laugh & "one of the lads" on the show, his departure was the one I was more disappointed with as he was more or less the "third man" of the team, usually being sent on special missions when required.
In Rhys' case I quickly warmed to Will as his replacement as he had a bigger on air presence than Rhys & ultimately ended up being the longest serving producer of the Afternoon Show (just shy of three years), when Will left & he was replaced by Rachel it took me a long while to accept her as his replacement, she just wasn't Will. I like Rachel now of course but it took a while to like her, I think due to Will's departure I never really got into the Breakfast show until 2005.
In Melinda's case, it took me a month or so to adjust to Lizzie, however once Lizzie had an on air presence I actually liked her more than Melinda by the end of her run, because when you heard her on air you realised just how nutty she was at times, plus Chris & Dave called her a tart or slut or the like and she laughed it off, 99% of the time. I didn't really have any problems with Aled taking over as he seemed to be on the same level as Melinda & at times Lizzie so I did warm to him a lot quicker than I did Rachel.
If Dom was to leave it would take someone really special & unique to fill his void, otherwise every time you listen to the show you'd just be wondering "what would Dom have said in this situation" and just want him back every show.
Gaspode_The_Wonder_Dog wrote:Will was as much a part of the show as Dom is. Rhys reminds me a bit of Dom - or was he just a baldy too? Lizzy was really involved too.
People just have short memories.
Rhys & Dom were rather different, although Rhys was a laugh he had his "Producer head" on at times & so if a link was over running he'd usually be heard in the background shouting "it's time for a tune". Will on the other hand very rarely mentioned that they hadn't played a song for a while & there was often jibes at him not back timing to the news that often.
Will & Lizzie were a big part of the show, when Lizzie left I felt there was a bit of a hole left by her departure although Aled did soon prove to be a good replacement for her, now I can't imagine the show without Aled, if he left now it'd be very noticeable. As I said above however Will's departure was far more noticeable, so much so that the last four months of the Afternoon Show I didn't really tune in at all & I hardly tuned in for the first 18 months of the Breakfast Show either, it's only because the competition on Capital FM, Kiss 100, etc. was so poor that I decided to tune back in & since then I've never looked back and have regretted not listening more during those times.
Regards, Johnny 1989
The Chris Moyles and Mark & Lard Archive:
Ongoing updates in the Moyles and Mark & Lard Archive:New Thread updated Weekly