[Sidders]

I thought the whole idea of the golden hour game in general was to vote for the song which you like the most. I don't see why this week there should be any exception just because others are picking songs that they hate.

It's true that I do normally vote for my own choice, because clearly it's going to be the song that I like the most, which is the reason I would have chose it. The only exception is when someone picks a song I like more before me.

[DevilsDuck]

Well I voted for the song I hate the most

[Sidders]

This game should be declaired null and void because everyone's playing by different criteria. Stupid choice in the first place IMO.

[DevilsDuck]

I agree

[bmstinton93]

I also agree

[John22]

I'm not sure about declaring it null and void, but this will for sure be the last game whilst I have anything to do with it where anything other than 'best' categories are allowed.

[MK Chris]

I reckon it should have been songs you love that you wouldn't necessarily associate with you - to really tie in with the show feature.

[bmstinton93]

So guilty pleasures then basically

[Nicola_Red]

That's a good idea, altho do we know each other well enough to know which songs we would/wouldn't associate with each other...?

[Yudster]

I like the idea of picking a song that makes us think of someone else on the forum. I think I've said this before - and also acknowledged the inherent personal danger in the idea. I still like it though.

[chrysostom]

match these songs to the member :

[bmstinton93]

Can you state which songs they are as I can't see on my phone. And i like yuds' idea

[John22]

Ok, nade won but I think we should be open to any suggestions this week. I like all the ideas so far, any one else got a favourite?

[bmstinton93]

I think Nade should still get the chance to pick.

[John22]

Ok, nade can choose if he wants, I'm happy to just go with le flow here...

[Boboff]

I pick 1942.

[nade]

The only thought I had would be to offer your favourite song from the year of your birth.

But i'm more than happy for the idea above if nobody likes this one.

[foot-loose]

I'd like so support DimTim here - I thought this GHG had the most potential for entertaining discussion in ages. It's not his fault if the rules were not clearly explained.

[Johnny 1989]

match these songs to the member :

1. Viv
2. Nicola Red
3. Boboff

[bmstinton93]

The only thought I had would be to offer your favourite song from the year of your birth.

But i'm more than happy for the idea above if nobody likes this one.

But then Yuds won't be able to enter...

[Bas]

2. Nicola Red

That was my very first thought too.

[Sidders]

I'd like so support DimTim here - I thought this GHG had the most potential for entertaining discussion in ages. It's not his fault if the rules were not clearly explained.

You're only saying that so he doesn't have a tantrum. Again.

[John22]

Ok, what do people want.

Song that reminds you of someone on the forum

or

Song from year of birth?

[MK Chris]

Year of birth, since it was suggested by the winner.

[Johnny 1989]

Year of birth, less of a headache, although the "song that reminds you of someone" is a good idea, I can see people getting confused like they did with this one.