Yudster wrote:Is there an element of young English players not getting a look in at top teams due to the proliferation of overseas players? Is it somehow cheaper for teams to buy in talent from abroad than develop it over time at home?
I think it depends on the team - Everton for example have had to rely on the ability to sell our best players in order to survive - so developing good young English players has been absolutely essential.
I think there are probably more clubs like Everton than there are like Man City (in terms of recent development of youth players) and so while the idea of English players not getting a chance, and somehow being lost to the game seems to make sense logically (you can see a cause and effect) I just don't think it's true - I think that the comparatively best players will always come through, if for no other reason than it makes financial sense.
We've only been buying in cheap young players from the continent for the last 15-20 years (at the very most), but we've been rubbish internationally for 40 years.
I think we've isolated ourselves and fallen for the media propaganda and hype - the "best league in the world" featuring "England's Golden generation" and featuring "great" players isn't the best league in the world, doesn't feature a golden generation and doesn't have truly great players.
Personally I think the reasons are coaching - we favour big strong lads who can run all day over technically skilful players who might (at the age of 12) be a bit flighty and lack concentration.