- Mon Aug 05, 2013 10:16 am
#498629
I'm extremely excited about Peter Capaldi as the Doctor.
I'm a big fan of Doctor Who, and when Matt Smith's appointment coincided with a spike in interest from America in anything English - it seemed like the beginning of the end for the series. Many of the storylines and episodes have been geared towards the 'One Direction' market, looking to accentuate the Doctor's quirkiness and general hipster tendencies - as well as forcing romantic links into every episode. This desperate need for teenage fangirls to be attracted to an actor portraying the role of the Doctor is tedious, but I understand why the BBC feel the need to play up to it.
By having an older actor portray the Doctor, it may shed a lot of the 'flash in the pan' support which has somewhat influenced the direction of the show in what I think is a negative way. It leaves potential for the character of the Doctor to take center stage as opposed to the actor playing him - something which I think Ecclestone did incredibly, and Tennant did very well.
I think Moffat (head writer) has seen that the show is at a tipping point - and if it becomes more 'international' then there may be no way back for the next writer to come along and put a traditional Doctor in the role.
But we should remember that Capaldi hasn't even uttered a word as The Doctor yet! He's a talented actor, and his Doctor will have his own personality. Presumably he's talented enough to be able to portray him as a nice person, or horrible, or troubled, or eccentric etc, etc.
I think he has a great look for the Doctor, and when watching the show I prefer an older character as the crux of a show as it connotes life experience and a deeper level of understanding - but then again the Doctor is over 900 years old!
If Cumberbatch wasn't such a skilled actor, I don't think I'd be able to take such a young Sherlock Holmes seriously. Also, Sherlock won't be back until October at the earliest, February at the latest. Here's the Series 3 trailer: